The Evidence Brief

The brands paying to test their competitors' products

NOW and Cata-Kor paid for lab tests of their competitors' products and published what came back, and a new nonprofit is now doing the same.

Two brands have paid for independent lab testing of their direct competitors recently and published what came back. In both cases the company publishing the results came out of it well.

In June, NOW bought vitamin C gummies from 30 different brands on Amazon and had them tested for how much vitamin C they actually contained. Five of the 30 were established brands it expected to pass, and they did, but the other 25 were listings whose labelling had already raised questions, and those are the ones that came back short. Only 13 of those matched the label, while twelve contained almost no vitamin C at all, including five that promised 1,000 mg or more per gummy and came back under 2 mg. NOW launched its own vitamin C gummy in April.

Cata-Kor did something similar in glutathione, having twelve top-selling Amazon products tested between April and June. Six of the twelve did not contain the amount of glutathione on the label, two had none in them at all, and one that promised 1,000 mg came back under 20 mg. In August, Cata-Kor's own glutathione picked up NSF/ANSI 173 certification.

Somebody is now doing this without a product to sell. The Future Nutra Foundation launched in April as a registered nonprofit with its own scientific advisory board, publishing its testing openly with no paywall. Electrolytes came first, where 15 brands went to two independent labs and most of them met label, and the ones that did not were contacted for improvement rather than named. In July it turned to hemp-derived delta-9 THC drinks and the picture was very different, because of 21 products sent to three separate labs only four came back within the accuracy window it had set. Lion's mane is next.

Our read

As a way of differentiating from the brands undercutting you on price, this is powerful marketing. It costs a few thousand, and the numbers do the talking. But it only separates you from the sellers getting it wrong. Against a competitor whose product contains exactly what it says on the label, everyone is back to arguing about who has the better formula, and a potency test won't help with that.

Sources: NOW testing announcement, Cata-Kor testing announcement, Future Nutra Foundation launch

Get The Evidence Brief

Industry news filtered down to the stories that show how health brands use science to win, every other Wednesday.

Subscribe