The Evidence Brief

Women are buying creatine for brain fog, not for the gym

Three brands launched within a week this August to sell creatine for the brain and bone, in the areas where the research is furthest behind.

Creatine's buyer is changing and the benefits they want out of it have changed with them. NutraIngredients analysis of the female buyer puts mental clarity at the top of the list, with strength and recovery below it, which is a flip of how the category has sold itself for thirty years.

Where there's a new audience there's a new market, and brands launch to make the most of it. Tonic Health, Creatonics and Arrival Wellness all came to market inside a week this August, and none of them are selling strength.

Tonic went with Creatine + Brain at 10 g a serving, double the standard dose, on the argument that muscle takes up creatine before the brain does and most products are too small to shift brain stores at all. Nobody has actually established what dose does reach the brain, which is what makes that a position rather than a spec.

Creatonics went at midlife, splitting the dose across a day and a night blend to avoid the stomach trouble a single large serving brings, and building the rest of the formula around bone, hormones and sleep. Arrival Wellness, women-founded and built entirely around monohydrate, launched single-serve sachets after its founder's mother was diagnosed with osteopenia, which puts bone at the centre of the brand rather than the label.

Brain and bone are also where the research is furthest behind. Thirty years of creatine studies sit mostly on muscle in younger men, the largest trial in postmenopausal women ran for two years without improving bone density, and Darren Candow, one of the most published researchers in the field, put out a review in January saying the efficacy of creatine in the brain remains largely unknown.

Sources: NutraIngredients analysis, Tonic Health, Creatonics, Arrival Wellness, Candow review, EFSA opinion

Get The Evidence Brief

Industry news filtered down to the stories that show how health brands use science to win, every other Wednesday.

Subscribe